What Are Error Coins? How Much Are Coin Mistakes Worth?

south-dakota-quarter-wth-no-silver-by-mcskeletor.jpg Have you ever heard about error coins?

Simply put, an error coin is a mint-made mistake — in the process of creating the coin at the U.S. mint, some sort of mistake was made affecting the “look” of the coin itself.

There are many types of error coins, and the exciting thing about error coins is that they can often be be found in circulation.

Here’s the kicker: error coins are often worth hundreds and even thousands of dollars!

 

Types Of Error Coins

Error coins as a category are usually divided by the type of error, of which there are several.

Some of the most common errors include:

  • Doubled-dies
  • Blank planchets
  • Broad strikes
  • Wrong design or wrong metal
  • Off-center coins
  • Clipped planchets

Bear in mind, this list is by no means exhaustive. There are dozens of recognized errors; the 6 mentioned here are major error types and are presented to help introduce you to the larger realm of error coin collecting.

 

Popular Coin Mistakes

Doubled-dies may be one of the most popular types of errors. A doubled-die refers to the doubling of all or part of the image on a coin. Typically, the doubling is confined to one side of a coin, and it is normally best seen in the lettering of a coin. However, parts of the design image can also show doubling effects, if the doubling is prominent enough. Perhaps one of the most famous errors of all time is the 1955 doubled-die Lincoln penny. Worth almost $1,000 in well-worn condition, the 1955 doubled-die penny has been drawing mainstream attention for over 50 years.

Blank planchets are not hard to spot, if you are lucky enough to locate one. (By the way, a “planchet” is simply the round piece of metal a coin is made from.) The result is a blank piece of metal that is the same size, shape, and color as a typical coin. Some are worth only a few dollars, but many are valued $10 to $20 and up.

Broad strikes are fairly valuable. When coins are struck at the U.S. Mint, they usually are momentarily placed inside a collar during the striking process to help create a properly formed rim. When the coin is not inserted inside the collar, the coin will tend to spread out a bit upon being struck. The result is a coin with an odd-looking rim (if there even is any), and the design may be off-center. The coin will also often be wider than it is supposed to be. This type of error is called a broadstrike. Depending on the type of coin, relative over-width of the coin, and the centering of the design, broadstrikes are worth anywhere from $5 to over $200.

Coins struck with the wrong metal or wrong design are always in demand. One of the most famous examples of coins struck on the wrong metal are the few 1943 pennies that were struck on bronze planchets instead of the steel rounds intended for 1943 cents. Lincoln penny designs on dime planchets, Washington quarter designs on nickel planchets, and so forth are common examples of “wrong design” errors. Some of these errors are worth thousands of dollars.

Off-center coins are often quite eye-catching. Some off-center errors are off by more than 50%, meaning only half the design has been struck on the coin, the other half of the coin is typically blank. With off-center coins, the values usually escalate as more and more of the design is missing, and prices do vary widely, depending on the type of coin. Many are worth $50 and up, and several are worth well into the hundreds of dollars.

Clipped planchets are the final type of error coin we’ll discuss here. The device which cuts the planchets out of the huge strips of metal that first enter the mint sometimes cuts a planchet more than once. When this happens, it can cut away a portion of the planchet, resulting in various-sized crescents. Most clipped coins are worth between $5 and $100, depending on the type of coin, grade, amount of missing metal, etc.

 

Other Types Of Error Coins

Remember, these are just a few of the many interesting and exciting types of error coins. There are many more types of coin mistakes, some of which are illustrated below:

Joshua McMorrow-Hernandez

My love for coins and numismatics began when I was 11 years old. I primarily collect and study U.S. coins produced during the 20th century. I've also been studying meteorology and watching weather patterns for years. I enjoy sharing little-known facts and fun stuff about coins, weather, travel, health, and living green with others.

More Posts

Find me here:
Google Plus

  • mike

    I have 2 pennies that have small bubbles on them. is this rare?

  • Anonymous

    I’m thinking about buying a 2009 Ultra High Relief Mint Error MS69. Does anyone know how much I should pay?

  • Steph70764

    I have a 1964-D Jefferson nickels appeared with PLURIBUS
    misspelled as PLURIDUS is this coin worth anything

    • Anonymous

      Steph,

      Your nickel is probably a filled die. Though interesting, there really isn’t much added monetary value. However, your best chance of making money from the coin should you decide to sell is to show the piece to error coin collectors — they will be most interested in buying the piece.

  • Joanne

    I was checking my coins today, and found a 2002 dime, which the last 2 is very hard to even see. I didn’t find anything in my guide (2011) about that year of any found, would it be called under-strikes? Just wondering if you’ve seen anything concerning that. I put another same year next to it, which actually was a bit worn looking, and definately different stamping, way more clear.

  • Joanne

    I was checking my coins today, and found a 2002 dime, which the last 2 is very hard to even see. I didn’t find anything in my guide (2011) about that year of any found, would it be called under-strikes? Just wondering if you’ve seen anything concerning that. I put another same year next to it, which actually was a bit worn looking, and definately different stamping, way more clear.

    • Anonymous

      Hi, Joanne –

      It sounds like a fairly typical situation where the dime was weakly struck or there was grease in die (the device that impresses a design onto a blank coin). I’ve seen many dimes and pennies that have weakness in the last digit of the date.

      While these types of coins are a bit of a curiosity, they really aren’t worth anything extra because of the weakness.

    • Anonymous

      Hi, Joanne –

      It sounds like a fairly typical situation where the dime was weakly struck or there was grease in die (the device that impresses a design onto a blank coin). I’ve seen many dimes and pennies that have weakness in the last digit of the date.

      While these types of coins are a bit of a curiosity, they really aren’t worth anything extra because of the weakness.

  • thomas dunne

    hi i have a 1847 usa one cent but there ia a mint error on the spelling. it says one cunt and theother side is the head wich is upside down. IS this cent any value. kind regards tom dunne

    • Anonymous

      Thomas,

      There’s been no reported error like that — it sounds like someone altered your 1847 cent, and that means it wouldn’t have much value in the numismatic market; I don’t know the grade of the coin, but an altered piece like that, in typical, well-worn grades might bring only a few dollars.

    • Anonymous

      Thomas,

      There’s been no reported error like that — it sounds like someone altered your 1847 cent, and that means it wouldn’t have much value in the numismatic market; I don’t know the grade of the coin, but an altered piece like that, in typical, well-worn grades might bring only a few dollars.

  • thomas dunne

    hi i have a 1847 usa one cent but there ia a mint error on the spelling. it says one cunt and theother side is the head wich is upside down. IS this cent any value. kind regards tom dunne

  • M Carl

    Josh, today I came across a 1951D penny that looked strange. It was only about 3/4 the thickness of a regular cent and the back was not stamped at all. Looking at the back side you can see a very slight indentation where Lincoln’s head appears. The rear has the raised ring around the outside edge. What should I do with this thing?

  • M Carl

    Josh, today I came across a 1951D penny that looked strange. It was only about 3/4 the thickness of a regular cent and the back was not stamped at all. Looking at the back side you can see a very slight indentation where Lincoln’s head appears. The rear has the raised ring around the outside edge. What should I do with this thing?

  • Quijada Yvonne

    im looking for a price on a silver doller thats from 1922 1923 that has a mistake on it the u is a v over it

    • Anonymous

      Hi, Quijada –

      The “V” is supposed to be there; it’s a stylized way of writing the “U” in IN GOD WE TRUST. The value of your coin is around $25 to $30.

  • Glassmom46545

    I have a 2010 dime that is smaller than a regular dime, and the edge is smooth copper like a penny.  Is this a real “error” that could be worth something?

    • Anonymous

      Hmm… Would you mind posting a pic on the Fun Times Guide to Coins Facebook page? Thanks. Here’s the link: http://www.facebook.com/#!/TheFunTimesGuideToCoins

      • Sgrands

        I have a 1967 dime that is the same description. The copper edge is raised quite a bit too.

  • Nicoledumarce_14

    my boyfriend has a two headed quarter, i wanted to know if it was actually worth anything.

    • Anonymous

      I’m afraid not, Nicole. These types of coins are common novelty pieces either altered from real coins or cast in a mold and are designed for winning bets (often as a joke) or as an interesting conversation piece.

  • Richard

    have lincoln cent with one cent writing beckward and on to writing the correct way and also the  united states is wring beckard but only some of the letters like you can only see ted and sta can anyone tell me the value of this coin

  • JoshuaTheFunTimesGuide

    That would be a vulgar novelty coin.

  • Animari369

     Maria Theresa
     Can You please tell me something about this quarter?

    • JoshuaTheFunTimesGuide

      Hi, Maria -

      That piece is quite something to look at, but because it is damaged, it’s worth only face value.

  • Rappman

    I have a 1992 quarter (Deleware state series) that appears to be similar to the one pictured above the Face side is copper and the reverse side is silver in color, one layer appears to have been missing when the coin was struck, do you have any idea of the value?

  • Coleman16

    i have a 1967 u.s half dollar with a detachabel collar on the outside of the coin. no idea what it’s for, thought it was a war medal. any help would be appreciated.

  • Rachelle Duran

    I have four wheat pennies and I wanted to no how much they could be worth, the years are between 1951-1957 and are in great condition.

    • JoshuaTheFunTimesGuide

      Hi, Rachelle, -

      Lincoln wheat cents are in general rather common, even though they aren’t found much in circulation anymore. Except for the 1955 doubled die cent (the date and lettering on the obverse side of this coin appears to have a secondary, ghost image), any worn Lincoln cents during the 1951 to 1957 era you mentioned are worth around 3 to 5 cents each. By the way, the 1955 doubled die cent is worth around $1,000 and up.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Ironicmike Mike Moran

    i have a u.s dime that is smaller than normal ,also has tall outer edge like it was pressed wrong could it be worth anything

  • aaron

    i have a penny one side is a 1951 with no mint mark and the otherside is a 1952 with a denver mint mark . is there any value in it .

    • JoshuaTheFunTimesGuide

      Hi, Aaron -

      What you have is a novelty coin, most likely used either as a sight gag for an illusionist or a piece made to “win” coin tosses. These don’t really have any numismatic value.

  • ed

    I have a colorado quarter that is not the right metal make up. The color is off and itts lighter in edight and sounds like silver

    • JoshuaTheFunTimesGuide

      Hi, Ed -

      A silver quarter would actually weigh more than a typical copper-nickel clad quarter, not less. You may have an aluminum replica or something of the sort, though by law a coin replica should say “copy” on it.

  • Kurt Kriescher

    I have a 1944-D zinc coated steel penny how much is that

  • Albert

    i have a wheat penny with only the year number of 195 does it have any value

    • JoshuaTheFunTimesGuide

      Hi, Albert -

      Thanks for your question. There really is no added value to such a coin.

  • http://www.facebook.com/angela.carcifiernst Angela Carcifi-Ernst

    Hello. I found a Lincoln Memorial coin…it has his bio on one side than his picture on the other. Do you happen to know where this was from? Also, I have a 1980 penny and the one side is thicker than the other…thank you

  • m410@tirekingdom.com

    i have a half struck dime mint error. what is it worth in good condition?

    • JoshuaTheFunTimesGuide

      A half off-center dime is worth around $5 to $20, based largely on if the date is evident (worth more in that case).

  • gwen

    HI I HAVE THIS COIN THAT WAS MADE IN 1942 THE FRONT HAS THE MERCURY WING HEAD LIKE THE DIME HOWEVER THE BACK HAS THE MONTICELLO FIVE CENTS MINT S . CAN’T FIND OUT ONLINE.
    Gwen

    • JoshuaTheFunTimesGuide

      Hi, Gwen -

      You seem to be describing a novelty coin; either it is two halves, one side consisting of a 1942 Mercury dime and the other an S-mint Jefferson nickel, soldered together, or the piece is a token made by an enterprising individual as a gag effect, perhaps for a magic trick.

  • eva

    I have a 1941 dime with awheat penny on the other side is it real?

    • JoshuaTheFunTimesGuide

      Hi, Eva -

      What you have is a type of novelty coin, and perhaps quite likely a piece intended as an illusion for a magician. Though a neat conversation piece, it was not originally made that way at the U.S. Mint and is not really worth more than a couple dollars.

      Thank you for your question!