The Flying Eagle Cent Was The First Small Penny – See Current Values

Most people probably think of Indian Head cents when they think about really old pennies.

However, before the Civil War — and before Indian Head pennies — there were Flying Eagle cents.

Flying Eagle cents, which were struck for 3 short years (1856 to 1858) were actually the very first small size pennies.

Before Flying Eagle cents, there were large cents. Large cents, most of which were almost the diameter of a half-dollar, were struck from 1793 to 1857.

Which Flying Eagle Cents Are Rare?

For being such an old coin, Flying Eagle cents really are not rare as a type.

However, the 1856 Flying Eagle cent is considered very rare.

The 1856 Flying Eagle cent is being sold for nearly $7,000 and up, even in well-circulated grades. Only about 1,000 were struck and, in every sense of the word, the 1856 Flying Eagle penny is the very first of the small cents.

However, 1857 and 1858 Flying Eagle cents are far more common, with more than 40 million (combined) originally struck. But far less than that survive today. Many of those which are still known to exist have been cleaned or are corroded, scratched, or otherwise damaged.

Finding a nicely worn Flying Eagle cent without any notable problems is important. Don’t settle on the first Flying Eagle cent you find! Avoid those which are discolored or pitted. If buying for a type set, spend the extra few dollars and buy a nice quality piece.

How Much Are Flying Eagle Cents Worth Today?

The Flying Eagle cent has risen in price considerably over the past 10 years or so with nice, circulated pieces now costing $30 to $50, compared to around $20 in the 1990s.

As mentioned earlier, the 1856 is by far the rarest of the Flying Eagle cents at almost $7,000 in heavily circulated grades.

In fact, including variations in lettering and the date, there are at least 5 different Flying Eagle cents in the Flying Eagle cent series. Counting doubled dies and other variations, there are several more.

Here are approximate prices for the 5 primarily collected Flying Eagle cents:

• 1856 Flying Eagle cent — $6,700 to $24,000 for Good-4 to Mint State-63
• 1857 Flying Eagle cent — $27 to $850 for Good-4 to Mint State-63
• 1858 Flying Eagle cent with Large Letters — $27 to $850 for Good-4 to Mint State-63
• 1858 Flying Eagle cent with Small Letters — $27 to $950 for Good-4 to Mint State-63
• 1858 Flying Eagle cent 8 over 7 — $75 to $12,000 for Good-4 to Mint State-63

*Values obtained from the Professional Coin Grading Service‘s (PCGS) coin prices website.

Ways To Collect Flying Eagle Cents

Here are the primary ways that people are collecting Flying Eagle cents today:

• There are people who specialize in and collect only Flying Eagle cents.
• There are many more people who would include Flying Eagle cents as part of a “type” collection.
• There are also coin collectors who place Flying Eagle cents into their collections as part of a penny collection.
• It is also the case that some coin collectors study and collect Flying Eagle cents with Indian Head pennies.

Where To Find A Flying Eagle Cent

Flying Eagle cents simply don’t circulate any more, as the coin is more than 150 years old and was removed from circulation by collectors many decades ago.

That said, it never hurts to check your pocket change, because Flying Eagle cents are indeed still legal tender.

If you want to get your hands on a Flying Eagle cent, be sure to check with a coin dealer. Many coin dealers, both online and brick & mortar, sell Flying Eagle cents. eBay is another place to find Flying Eagle cents.

Unless you are shopping for cheap deals, just be sure to avoid cleaned, corroded, and discolored Flying Eagle cents.

READ NEXT: A List Of The Rarest U.S. Coins