1916 Penny Value Guide: See How Much A 1916 Lincoln Cent Is Worth + A List Of Rare 1916 Wheat Penny Errors

A 1916 penny can be worth anywhere from a few cents to a few thousand dollars.

Knowing whether you’ve got a 1916 wheat penny with a value of 5 to 10 cents or one that’s worth the big bucks requires that you know a few things about your coin:

• Where it was minted
• The grade and overall condition of your coin
• The presence of any errors or die varieties

In this article, I’ll show you how to determine each of those things about your coin.

Plus, you’ll find out how many 1916 pennies were made, some interesting things about the design of Lincoln cents, and how much the most valuable 1916 penny sold for!

So let’s get started by exploring the 1916 penny value…

How Much Is A 1916 Penny Worth?

While it’s pretty hard to find a 1916 wheat penny in pocket change these days, 1916 pennies are not rare.

MUST READ: Rare Coins vs. Scarce Coins

Most are preserved for safe keeping in coin collections — and they’re generally worth only a small amount over face value.

How much your 1916 wheat penny is worth depends on which of the following you have:

• 1916 penny with no mintmark — A 1916 Lincoln wheat cent with no mintmark on the obverse (heads side) was made at the Philadelphia Mint. Among 1916 Lincoln wheat cents, those from the Philly mint are the most common and are usually worth 10 to 50 cents in well-worn (circulated)  condition. 1916 Lincoln cents with no mintmark in mint state (uncirculated) are worth anywhere from $20 to $50 for typical chocolate-brown specimens and more than $1,500 for superior examples with lustrous, original red surfaces.
• 1916-D penny — A 1916 Lincoln cent with a “D” mintmark was made at the Denver Mint and is relatively scarce. Values for a 1916-D penny range from $2 to $10 for significantly worn examples to $50+ for uncirculated specimens. As an example, an uncirculated 1916-D penny with original, red surfaces is worth anywhere from $100 to $10,000.
• 1916-S penny — A 1916-S Lincoln cent from the San Francisco Mint is also scarce. Values for a 1916-S penny range from $2 to $10 for heavily worn specimens to $100+ for uncirculated examples. Premium specimens with original red surfaces trade for more than $550.
• 1916 proof penny — 1916 proof Lincoln wheat cents were struck at the Philadelphia Mint for coin collectors. These old coins are considerably rare and range in value from $400 to $9,000. 

*Values listed above are for coins with no signs of damage — including cleanings, holes, bends, heavy nicks, or other types of problems. 

IMPORTANT: What Is The Grade Of Your 1916 Penny?

To determine the true value of your 1916 wheat penny, you first need to know what condition (or grade) your coin is in.

---

COIN TIP: These coin grading apps make grading coins yourself SO much easier!

How Much Are Rare 1916 Wheat Penny Errors Worth?

1916 pennies with mistakes are hard to find — but they’re definitely worth looking for!

Many 1916 Lincoln cents with errors and unusual varieties range in value from $10 to more than $100.

Here’s a rundown on the value of 1916 wheat penny errors:

• 1916 doubled die pennies — There is at least one known 1916 Lincoln doubled die cent, with this variety boasting thickness in the motto E PLURIBUS UNUM and the wheat stalks on the reverse (tails side). These doubled die pennies don’t trade often, so market values range widely. Similar doubled die pennies trade between $25 to $50… or more.
• 1916 off-center pennies — Some 1916 pennies weren’t struck perfectly centered, and pieces that are off-center are worth a decent premium. A 1916 penny that’s 5% to 10% off-center is worth $10 to $20. Those with more significant error strikes of perhaps 50% or more off-center have values soaring into the hundreds of dollars.
• 1916 pennies with die cracks or die cuds — Some 1916 Lincoln pennies have raised bumps and bulges caused by damage to the die, which strikes designs on blank coins. Die cracks can occur anywhere on the coin’s surface, whereas die cuds are raised bumps attached to the rim. A 1916 Lincoln cent with a minor die crack or die chip (a very small, blobby type of die break) may be worth $3 to $5. A 1916 Lincoln wheat cent with a major die cud could fetch $100 to $200… perhaps even more.
• 1916 pennies with repunched mintmarks — A repunched mintmark occurs when the working coin die was stamped at least twice by the mintmark letter punch. Such errors are normally regarded as minor by many collectors and may have values of $5 to $20.

Error coins are scarce by nature — so if you find an unusual or odd-looking 1916 Lincoln penny, be sure to keep it. After all, 1916 error pennies are cool old coins that can be worth big money!

---

Fun Facts About 1916 Pennies

Old pennies have lots of stories to tell!

Here are some neat facts about 1916 pennies…

#1 – What’s the most valuable 1916 wheat penny?

It’s a 1916-D penny that was certified by Professional Coin Grading Service as Mint State-67 Red — it sold for $58,750 in February 2016.

#2 – How many 1916 wheat cents were made?

Here’s a breakdown of mintage numbers, by mintmark and type:

• 1916 no mintmark (Philadelphia Mint) — 131,832,627 minted
• 1916-D penny (Denver Mint) — 35,956,000
• 1916-S penny (San Francisco Mint) — 22,510,000
• 1916 proof penny (Philadelphia Mint) — 1,050

#3 – Who designed the 1916 Lincoln cent?

Victor David Brenner designed the first Lincoln pennies in 1909. His original design incorporated his initials (VDB) on the reverse underneath the wheat stalks. Brenner’s initials were removed from that spot later in 1909, and they were restored on the coin in 1918. The wheat stalk design — symbolizing national prosperity — was replaced in 1959 by the Lincoln Memorial penny.