What’s the Most Expensive Coin Ever Sold?

by

Joshua

Coin Values, Hobbies & Crafts

This post may contain affiliate links. If you buy thru these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

most-expensive-coinDid you hear about the 1794 United States silver dollar that auctioned for more than $10 million in January 2013?

Now the most expensive coin ever sold, the 1794 Flowing Hair dollar was the first silver dollar ever officially minted in the United States. A coin that most collectors (including myself) would have loved to place a bid on, the specimen that sold for $10 million is considered by several consummate numismatists to have been among the first very few made, if not actually the first ever made.

It’s the allure that such a coin may have been touched by George Washington or our other Founding Fathers that is part of the reason people are drawn to old, rare U.S. coins like the 1794 silver dollar. Another thing that makes old coins like the 1794 dollar coin so sought after is that they physically embody the very essence of our country’s earliest times as a nation.

 


Old Silver Dollars: Historic Vessels Of Our Nation’s History

Our young nation was still sorting many operational matters out during the last decade of the 18th century, and one of those issues was finalizing an official monetary system for our country. Many pattern coins were made as test pieces during the early 1790s, but it was the 1794 silver dollar that would be the first official United States currency bearing the face value of our monetary basis unit, the dollar (paper currency would not be authorized until the Civil War, by the way).

Imagine holding a coin that is nearly as old as the United States! I once held a 1799 silver dollar, and upon closing my eyes with the heavy, silver coin in my hand, imagined all the incredible stories it was trying to tell me.

Of course, a coin like the 1794 Flowing Hair silver dollar would also have many tales to tell. And, if the $10 million specimen indeed was the very first dollar coin ever made, it would definitely take the cake as the most interesting coin in my collection. The question I ask is what is the greater claim to fame? First dollar coin ever made or most expensive coin? Perhaps I’d need to flip that coin to get the answer. (Numismatists, I am only kidding about flipping a 1794 silver dollar).

 

The 1933 Double Eagle Gold Coin – The Previously Most Expensive Coin

If you want to hear about another coin with a really interesting story, perhaps you’d like to learn more about the 1933 Saint-Gaudens double eagle gold coin. This coin, with a face value of $20, was the most expensive coin ever sold until the 1794 Flowing Hair dollar hit the auction block in January 2013. What was the final price of the 1933 double eagle coin, you may ask? Read on to find out!

The 1933 $20 double eagle didn’t start out as a particularly rare coin. In fact, more than 445,000 were minted. However, none of these were released into circulation because that same year, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt took the United States off the gold standard.

Virtually all 1933 $20 gold double eagles were then melted to become gold bullion. United States government officials had believed only two pieces, which the U.S. Mint gifted to the U.S. National Numismatic Collection at the Smithsonian Institute, had escaped melting. However, a handful of other 1933 double eagle coins soon began surfacing.

As some historians believe, a mint cashier named George McCann had taken roughly 20 1933 double eagle coins that were on the way to the melting vat and replaced them with double eagles of earlier dates, keeping the accounting books balanced.

Eventually, many of these coins found their way to Israel Switt, who was a jeweler in the Philadelphia area. Switt later sold nine of these to various coin collectors, and one came into the possession of King Farouk of Egypt. The Secret Service was able to confiscate all but the Farouk specimen, which eventually appeared in New York in the 1970s in the hands of British coin dealer Stephen Fenton.

The Secret Service confiscated the coin during a sting operation, but Fenton fought the law on the seizure. The coin was stored in U.S. Treasury vaults at the World Trade Center in New York City but was removed, only two months before the 9/11 terrorist attacks, when Fenton and the U.S. government agreed on a compromise; the deal involved selling the coin at auction, with the earnings being split between Fenton and the U.S. Mint.

What was the final price of the 1933 double eagle gold coin? Try more than $7.5 million! While the buyer of this famous coin hasn’t been officially disclosed, I can break the news to you now that it wasn’t me.

Don’t miss our latest tips!

Stay up to date with everything about U.S Coins

We don’t spam! Read more in our privacy policy

Previous

The Ultimate Guide To The 1944 Steel Penny: Like 1943 Copper Cents, It’s A Rare Coin That Collectors Crave

Next

Have A Silver Penny? Here’s How to Find Out Whether You Have An Error Coin, A Rare Coin, Or A Damaged Coin

23 thoughts on “What’s the Most Expensive Coin Ever Sold?”

  1. Weren’t there some nickels, of which only a few test samples were minted, that were picked up off the street after a car accident? I’m going to search on-line to see if I can find the story.

    Reply

  3. Hi Ryan, I have a coin which someone claimed that he has sold one of them few years ago at about $2,000,000. How possible is that? I have the picture of the coin.

    Reply

      • Hi Joshua! These are the pictures, I was able to see Divafay Stina on google but do not know how accurate and the claim of being sold $2,000,000 is possible where as it`s not among the most expensive coins I could found online. Do you have a clue or the possible price it worth? Thanks!

        Reply

        • Hi, Damian —

          This appears to be a Roman gold Faustina coin, minted approximately 27 BC-476 AD. I know that authentic pieces are worth $5,000 to $10,000, but I have never personally heard of one coming anywhere close to $2 million.

          This may be an authentic coin, but (often) such valuable pieces are usually certified by third-party coin grading companies these days. That doesn’t suggest this is a replica, though it may be and therefore should therefore be authenticated by a professional who can see and weigh this coin in-hand.

          I hope this helps,
          Josh

          Reply

          • Thanks Joshua! What about the second coin Antonio Pius? He actually told me today that it was Antonio Pius that he sold $2,000,000. How can I get a third party who can weigh the coin?

          • Hi, Damian —

            Third-party coin authentication is a service you pay for that costs between $15 and $30 per coin, though of course an amount well worth the price when talking about any coin worth hundreds of dollars or more.

            Here’s more info on coin graders (also referred to by many as coin “slabbers”): https://coins.thefuntimesguide.com/slabbed_coins/

            Good luck,
            Josh

  4. Hi Ryan, I have two gold coins and I wonder if you could give me an idea of how much they value. They were given to me by my grandmother. I believe they are European coins. Below is a picture of my coins. Please tell me what you think. Thanks in advance.

    Reply

    • Nina,

      The value of your coin all depends on its condition and whether or not your coin has a mintmark; here is some more info about mintmarks: https://coins.thefuntimesguide.com/mint_marks_letters_on_coins/

      What I can tell you is that your coin is worth at least $12 based on the current melt value of silver plus the nominal collector value of a well-worn Barber half dollar.

      If you would like to submit a photo of your coin, I would be glad to examine it and give you more specific information about your piece.

      Have a great day,
      Josh

      Reply

  6. hello sir,

    i have also one us dollar 1891. so i want to sell it……and so many other antique us coin also…

    thanks
    jignesh bhatt….

    Reply

    • Hello, Jignesh —

      If you’re interested in selling your 1891-O Morgan silver dollar, there are two options to consider:

      •Listing it on eBay
      •Selling it to your nearest coin dealer

      Your 1891-O is worth $25 to $30 USD, so if you’re looking to sell it, bear in mind the amount of profit you’ll be receiving for the trouble you went through to sell the coin.

      If you’re interested in selling your 1891-O Morgan dollar to a coin dealer, here are some tips to help you find a reputable shop: https://coins.thefuntimesguide.com/coin_dealer/

      Good luck!
      Josh

      Reply

  7. Hello . I have a 1922 silver dollar eagle coin and I also have over 300 cooper pennies, and 1920 to 1958 wheat pennies. I will like to kn where can i found a place to sell them and how much is worth.?

    Reply

Leave a Comment